Very little downside, huge upside. Try becoming a better human being, like my dad and my mom. People like that are admired. But if there's no God, why would that even matter?
Grey Swan Capital · Article
Taking Theology Risks: What Are the Odds?
Very little downside, huge upside. Try becoming a better human being, like my dad and my mom. People like that are admired. But if there's no God, why would that even matter?
This is the first Taking Theology Risks post, the faith half of a new series that pairs one good risk with technology and one good risk with faith. It started as a voice memo I recorded at 4:42 AM on Tuesday, Nov 17, 2026, on I-40, headed home. The quotes are mine, from that recording, lightly trimmed. Scripture is from the New Living Translation (NLT).
Cold Open: A Pause on the Highway
Interstate 40. Dark. A man talking to a recorder on his shirt.
I’d just finished an idea about trying a new AI habit, the kind of risk with very little downside and a huge upside. Then I asked myself the obvious next question.
“Okay, so how do you apply that to theology?”
And I answered it out loud:
“Wouldn’t it be better if you became a better human being? Like, is that really a bad risk to try to become a better human being? Well, what do we mean by a better human being? I don’t know. Maybe one that doesn’t lie as much, cheat as much, you know, cares about people more, does things for others, thinks about others more than he thinks about himself.”
Then there’s a pause in the recording. And I said three words.
“Like my dad.”
Another pause.
“And my mom.”
Scene 1: People Like That Are Admired
A kitchen table. Two chairs. You know the kind of people I mean.
I didn’t say more about my parents that morning, and I’m not going to dress it up now. I’ll just tell you what I said next, because it’s the whole question:
“You know, people like that are admired. Why? If there’s no God, why would that even matter?”
Think about the people you admire most. Not the famous ones. The ones you knew. The ones who told the truth when it cost them. Who showed up. Who thought about other people more than themselves.
Nobody has to be taught to admire that. We just do. Almost everybody does.
And that’s strange, if you think about it. If we’re just here by accident, and nothing is really right or wrong, then honesty is just a strategy and kindness is just a preference. Why would a selfless life move us the way it does? Why do we tell our kids, “Be like your grandpa”?
I think it matters because something real is behind it. That’s my conclusion, and I’m telling you it’s mine. But the question is yours to wrestle with either way.
Scene 2: The Risk
Same highway. The sky starting to grey.
So here’s the theological risk, in plain words.
Try becoming that kind of person. Lie less. Cheat less. Care more. Do things for others. Think about others more than yourself.
What’s the downside? If there’s no God, you spent your life being honest and kind. People admired you. Your family talks about you the way I talk about my dad and my mom. That’s a pretty good “worst case.”
What’s the upside? If there is a God, and he’s the God Jesus showed us, then you weren’t just being nice. You were walking toward him.
The Bible said it a long time ago: “The LORD has told you what is good, and this is what he requires of you: to do what is right, to love mercy, and to walk humbly with your God” (Micah 6:8, NLT).
And Paul: “Don’t look out only for your own interests, but take an interest in others, too” (Philippians 2:4, NLT).
Very little downside. Huge upside. These are the kind of risks you always want to take.
Scene 3: The Mathematician Who Did the Odds
Paris, 1654. Candlelight. A man who invented a piece of math.
I’m not the first person to think about faith this way. Not even close.
In the summer of 1654, a French mathematician named Blaise Pascal traded letters with Pierre de Fermat about a gambling problem: how to split the stakes fairly in a game that gets cut short. Out of those letters came the foundations of probability theory, the math of “what are the odds.”
That same year, on the night of November 23, 1654, from about 10:30 PM until about half past midnight, Pascal had an experience of God so overwhelming that he wrote it down on a scrap of paper. It begins with one word in capital letters, “FIRE,” and then, in a common English translation: “God of Abraham, God of Isaac, God of Jacob, not of the philosophers and scholars.”
He sewed that note into his coat and moved it from coat to coat for the rest of his life. Nobody knew about it until after he died, when a servant found it. It’s known today as Pascal’s Memorial.
Later, in notes published after his death as the Pensées, Pascal laid out what’s now called Pascal’s Wager. In rough paraphrase: if you bet your life on God and you’re right, you gain everything; if you’re wrong, you’ve lost very little. His own line, in a well-known English translation, is: “If you gain, you gain all; if you lose, you lose nothing.”
Some people don’t like the wager. They say you can’t bet your way into faith. That’s fair, and I don’t think Pascal meant it that way either. The man wasn’t converted by a math problem. He was converted by fire.
What I like about my dad-and-mom version is that it doesn’t start with a bet. It starts with something everybody already admires. Then it asks why.
Scene 4: Jesus Never Asked for a Bet
A road in Galilee. A man calling fishermen off their boats.
Here’s where the two risks meet.
Jesus never asked anybody to place a wager. He never even asked anybody to become a Christian. The word didn’t exist yet (Acts 11:26). What he said was, “Come, follow me” (Mark 1:17, NLT). Come and see. Kick the tires. Watch what I do.
That’s a low-risk invitation. You don’t have to sign anything. You just have to start walking, and see where it goes.
“Taste and see that the LORD is good” (Psalm 34:8, NLT).
Scene 5: Why This Is a Grey Swan
A grey swan, as we use the term, is something 80% likely to 100% inevitable, yet misunderstood or propagandized. They aren’t rare.
There’s one grey swan every single one of us faces at 100%. We’re each going to die. That’s not rare. That’s certain. And yet most of us plan for almost everything except the question of what it all meant.
Pascal took the odds seriously. So do the people we admire most, in the way they live. The question for the rest of us is whether we will.
Coming November 23: “What Are the Odds?”
On Monday, November 23, 2026, the 372nd anniversary of Pascal’s Memorial, we’re launching a new page called “What Are the Odds?” The plan is for it to walk through Pascal’s Wager, the mathematician behind it, and the question at the center of this series, in plain English, with sources.
We’ll post the link here and on our homepage when it’s live. Until then, start at
https://home.greyswancapital.ai/?go=theology
.
The AI half of this series is Taking AI Risks: Wear It 30 Days, on our Substack.
What Say You?
Who is the person you’d point to and say, “Like them”? A parent, a grandparent, a coach, a neighbor? What made them that way? Write me and tell me about them.
Then try the risk for thirty days. Lie less. Care more. Think about others first. See what happens.
What say you?
Read More
Jesus Never Told Anybody to Become a Christian: https://greyswancapital.substack.com/p/jesus-never-told-anybody-to-become
Steve’s paper, Better Than the Word: https://home.greyswancapital.ai/papers/better-than-the-word-steve-schroeder.pdf
Our theology work:
https://home.greyswancapital.ai/?go=theology
Ask me a question:
https://home.greyswancapital.ai/?go=ask
Start at
https://home.greyswancapital.ai/
.
Practical What To Do Next
You don’t have to take my word for any of this. Every source is linked below. Think of the person you’d point to and say, “Like them.” Then try their way of living for thirty days: lie less, care more, think about others first. Watch for the “What Are the Odds?” page on November 23.
Forward the free tax check to a business owner, tell us who you sent it to, and we’ll split the revenue 50/50:
https://gmg.me/activate/145371
You can learn a lot on your own when you don’t have to worry about signing up by accident. Click around freely, because signing up is always clear. If you have questions, email me at steve@greyswancapital.ai.
Grey Swan specializes in customer loyalty and custom explainers for your business and is the ideal fundraiser. Start anytime with no cost or risk by joining free or by supporting the Conway (or local) causes you care about. Start at
https://home.greyswancapital.ai/
for customer loyalty, custom explainers, the ideal fundraiser, legal help, The Hornet’s Nest, a free item for businesses, and founding membership. You can join free.
Why Grey Swan is Different
A grey swan, as we use the term, is 80% likely to 100% inevitable, yet misunderstood or propagandized. These events happen all the time. They aren’t rare. Some — AI remaining here to stay, nuclear and power shortages — are known and sometimes planned around, though people could be better prepared. Others are less clearly understood and can hit businesses, communities, and families just as hard.
Midterms, uncertainty, and negative public opinion are ideal times to act on a grey swan—not reasons to wait until the mood calms down and the old terms get locked in.
We show our sources and our unknowns, not just the verdict. Plain English. Humility. Room to change our minds when the facts do.
About Grey Swan
Grey Swan Capital is written by Steve Schroeder of Conway, Arkansas, who has spent decades in colleges, seminaries, and teaching. Find the work at
https://home.greyswancapital.ai/
and
. One membership covers both.
Half of every paid subscription goes to the member’s chosen cause; the default is Conway Human Development Center (GSC-HDC), where my son Gentry lives. Join for $6/month or $50/year, or become one of the first 1000 Founders at $200/year:
https://home.greyswancapital.ai/
.
Thank you, Steve Schroeder
Commentary and personal faith reflection, not legal, tax, or investment advice. Steve’s quotes come from his own voice memo recorded Nov 17, 2026 (Fieldy recording 352abd7f), lightly trimmed. Scripture quotations are from the New Living Translation (NLT). Pascal’s Memorial is quoted in a common English translation, and his wager line from the W. F. Trotter translation of the Pensées; the summary of the wager is a paraphrase. The header and social images are original Grey Swan graphics made with AI. The free tax check does not guarantee savings.
Sources (opened and checked Nov 18, 2026)
Wikipedia, “Blaise Pascal” (1654 Fermat correspondence; Memorial of Nov 23, 1654, 10:30–12:30 at night; sewn into his coat; found by a servant after his death): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blaise_Pascal
Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, “Pascal, Blaise” (Memorial text and translation): https://iep.utm.edu/pascal-b/
Christian Classics Ethereal Library, Pascal’s Memorial (French and English; Pensées published 1670): https://www.ccel.org/ccel/p/pascal/memorial/cache/memorial.pdf
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, “Pascal’s Wager” (quotes §233 of the Pensées, 1910 Trotter translation): https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/pascal-wager/
Eva (pronounced YEH-vuh) and Grok are AI characters. Their story is fiction. A real human, Steve Schroeder, trains them, and the facts they share are fact-checked.