Grey Swan Capital · Article
What Nostr Actually Is (And Why I'm Building Loyalty on It)
A plain-language look at an open protocol, why you should try Primal, and how I'm building loyalty on top of it.
Originally on Substack: https://greyswancapital.substack.com/p/what-nostr-actually-is-and-why-im
Most people have heard the word Nostr and still could not tell you what it is. I do not blame them. I have been living in this work, and I am still coming up with new pieces of it. We are just getting this ready, and it has not been easy.
Here is the plain version.
Nostr is not a company. It is not a single app. It is not a blockchain. Nostr means Notes and Other Stuff Transmitted by Relays. It is an open communications protocol: a shared set of rules that many apps can use, the way many email apps can all send mail.
The app you download is a client. The servers that store and deliver signed messages — called events — are relays. Your identity is a key pair: a public key you can share (it often starts with npub) and a private key you keep (it often starts with nsec). Anyone can build a client. Anyone can run a relay.
If that sounds technical, hold on. The point is simple. You are not renting a username from one company that can take the whole room away.
What open source actually means
A lot of Nostr is open source. That phrase gets used like a magic word, so let me say what it means and what it does not.
Open source means the code can be inspected, modified, and shared under a license. The benefits are real. People can see how the thing works. Independent people can find bugs and suggest fixes. If one project stalls, others can fork it and keep going. You are less locked in to a single vendor. Competing apps can try different layouts and different business models on the same network.
Open source is not automatically secure. It is not automatically free. And open source alone does not give you a portable identity. That part comes from Nostr’s keys and the shared protocol.
“Direction, not intention, determines destination.” — Andy Stanley, The Principle of the Path
Wanting an open internet is an intention. Building on a protocol other people can inspect and use is a direction.
The fastest way to understand it: download Primal
If you want to experience Nostr instead of only reading about it, download Primal from the Apple App Store or Google Play, or try it at primal.net.
Primal is one app for Nostr. It is not Nostr itself. The store listing mentions a built-in Bitcoin wallet; you do not need to buy Bitcoin just to look around.
Other clients include Damus on iPhone, Amethyst on Android, and Coracle on the web. Because they speak the same protocol, you can use the same Nostr identity when you switch apps. Your follows can come along when the relay data is available. Every old post may not look identical in every app, and that is all right. The identity is yours. The layout is the client’s job.
Why this is different from traditional media
I am not going to tell you every Nostr app already beats X, Facebook, or Instagram. That would not be honest. The audience is smaller. Some of the apps still feel rougher. What I can tell you are the architectural advantages — the reasons a person or a company might want this underneath the thing they are building.
You control your identity. Your key is not a username one company can delete everywhere at once.
It is censorship-resistant, not uncensorable. If one relay blocks you, another can still carry your posts. Governments, app stores, and relay operators can still restrict access. Anyone who tells you otherwise is selling a cartoon.
Your follows can travel with you. Switching Nostr apps need not mean rebuilding your network from scratch.
Many apps can share one network. Primal, Damus, Amethyst, and others can use the same identity and the same events.
You get more choice over feeds. The protocol does not impose one ranking algorithm on everybody. Clients may still add recommendations. Nostr is not a world with “no algorithms.” It is a world where the ranking is not the law of the whole network.
There are public relays, paid relays, private relays, and community relays. A business can run its own. That does not automatically encrypt everything on it.
The protocol does not require ads. Clients and relays can still add ads or charge fees. I will not tell you Nostr is always ad-free.
And a signature on a message proves the key authorized it. It does not prove the claim is true, and it does not prove the person is who they say they are. Verifiable authorship is not the same thing as virtue.
Encrypted messaging exists on Nostr, but it is not complete anonymity. People in high-risk situations should still use specialized messengers.
Bitcoin, zaps, and something more like cash
Bitcoin is optional on Nostr. You do not have to use it to read, write, or follow.
When people do use it here, one of the distinctive pieces is zaps: Lightning tips tied to Nostr posts and identities. Lightning is a way to send small, fast Bitcoin payments.
There is also Cashu, which is ecash: digital tokens that behave more like cash. Blind signatures help separate the moment the tokens are issued from the moment they are later spent. Nostr has optional standards for wallets and for “nutzaps.” The honest sentence, the one I will not skip, is this: users must trust the mint that holds the underlying funds.
Open standards — the community calls them NIPs — let the ecosystem grow past a Twitter-like feed into messaging, payments, communities, and specialized apps. Many of those standards are optional, so not every app supports every feature. That is not a failure. That is how a protocol stays a protocol instead of becoming another walled garden with a manifesto.
I look at Bitcoin’s issuance schedule, moving toward a 21 million cap under the current rules, and I see what I would call the hardest money: scarce issuance, not something a committee can print more of tomorrow. That is a viewpoint, not a trophy I can hand the whole world and call settled. “Cannot be printed” means those current issuance rules. I will not tell you it cannot be corrupted, and I will not pretend it is ultimate security. It is strong, and it is worth building around with both eyes open.
CLAAS, and the client I am actually building
CLAAS is my live loyalty offering and the foundation for my planned Nostr Fundraising client.
Here is what is already live, and it does not require Nostr yet. Merchants offer a free item. Members show a QR code. Half of paid memberships go to causes, and if someone does not pick one, that support goes to the HDCs, including the Conway HDC where my son Gentry lives. Because of the Nostr protocol, more of this can become turnkey later.
The client I am planning is not a typical X-style social feed. It is a custom layout for redeeming free items for paid subscribers, and a much stronger customer-loyalty platform on top of Nostr. That last part is the design goal. I will not stand here and call it a proven result before the results are in.
“Ye shall know them by their fruits.” — Jesus, Matthew 7:16
Better loyalty has to be shown, not assumed because the word Nostr is in the sentence.
What I can describe is the shape. The app can speak the same protocol as Primal, Damus, and the others, so it can still connect to the same network. Underneath, there is a shared social layer — identity, follows, posts, payments — plus a CLAAS interface for merchant offers, paid-member checks, QR codes, scanning, and redemptions, plus a business backend for subscriptions, limits, fraud checks, and cause accounting.
Members could use Primal or Damus for the social side and use my app for loyalty with the same identity, if that linking is done securely. Other clients will not automatically understand a custom coupon format unless that format is documented and adopted.
One more honest sentence, because this is where slogans get people in trouble: relays are not a global ledger. Preventing a free item from being redeemed twice requires our own redemption logic. A zap receipt alone should not unlock a paid benefit.
A turnkey idea: your own relay, your own rewards
Here is one idea I keep turning over.
A company could run its own private relay and offer custom Bitcoin-denominated rewards using ecash as a branded currency inside a community. A merchant funds the rewards. Members receive small amounts of ecash. Other merchants accept them. People spend them onward or redeem them through Lightning. The community relay carries the offers.
That is a proposed loop — a circular economy built around Bitcoin — not a promise of guaranteed prosperity.
Two details matter if you ever try it. The relay and the mint are different services. A branded reward is not Bitcoin unless it is actually backed and redeemable. Cashu tokens belong to the mint that issued them, and users have to trust that mint.
I think this can spread into communities that want something sturdier than points that expire when a marketing department gets bored. The process is the point. The verdict can wait until somebody has watched a real loop for a while.
What I want to put in front of Elon
I have put a proposal in front of Elon Musk.
A custom version of Nostr Fundraising as X Fundraising, inside X’s existing membership, as an X exclusive. Share the revenue 50/50. Open Nostr access through X and bring the two technologies together during a transition. I have more I would like to brainstorm with him, including theology and his pursuit of God, and how Grey Swan is addressing that on The Hornet’s Nest with Grok. All of this is synergistic. If he wanted to buy the company, I would be open to that.
That is a proposal, not a partnership. Building any of it inside X would still need his yes.
We have reached out to Elon and we are waiting for his reply. If the door opens, the hope is to have him on The Hornet’s Nest to announce something. That is a hope, not a booking.
“Stay committed to your decisions, but stay flexible in your approach.” — Tony Robbins
I am committed to building this. I am flexible about who helps carry it, and about how a bigger platform might meet an open protocol without pretending the deal is already done.
What I will not hide
If you lose your private key, there is no password-reset link waiting in your inbox. If someone steals it, they can impersonate you. Never paste an nsec into a random website.
Relays can go away or drop history. Open publishing still needs real moderation. Public posts are public. Payments can involve fees, price swings, and mint or custody risk.
“Tell the truth — or, at least, don’t lie.” — Jordan B. Peterson, 12 Rules for Life
The truth is that Nostr gives you a different foundation: your keys, many clients, relays you can choose, optional payments, and room to build something that does not have to look like a social feed. The truth is also that the foundation does not do the building for you.
Platforms changing the rules, and people discovering they never owned their identity there, is a grey swan: 80% likely to 100% inevitable. These events happen all the time; they are not rare. A lot of people do plan for them, many don’t, and some aren’t obvious enough that people even know to look. Some of this is known and sometimes planned around, though we could be better prepared.
I am planning around it by building in the open, keeping the loyalty offering live while the Nostr client gets ready, and inviting you to see the protocol for yourself.
Download Primal. Walk around. Then come back and look at what we are building at greyswancapital.ai. The website is the front door.
Teaching Outline
Nostr is an open communications protocol, not a company, a single app, or a blockchain.
Identity is a key pair you hold. Clients are apps. Relays store and deliver signed events.
Open source means the code can be inspected, modified, and shared — with real benefits and without magic promises.
The fastest way to experience Nostr is to download Primal; Primal is one client, not Nostr itself.
Architectural advantages over traditional media include portable identity, censorship resistance (not uncensorability), portable follows, and many apps on one network.
Bitcoin is optional. Zaps use Lightning. Cashu/ecash is more like cash, and users must trust the mint.
CLAAS is my live loyalty offering and the foundation for my planned Nostr Fundraising client; the live QR system does not require Nostr yet.
The planned client is a paid-subscriber loyalty and redemption layout, not a typical social feed, while still speaking the same protocol as Primal, Damus, and others.
A company could propose its own relay and Bitcoin-denominated ecash rewards as a circular-economy loop — a proposal, not a guarantee.
We have reached out to Elon with a proposed X collaboration that would still need his yes; having him on The Hornet’s Nest to announce something is a hope, not a booking.
Discussion:
Who actually owns your identity on the apps you use every day?
If you could take your follows with you, what would you stop being afraid to leave?
What would a loyalty program look like if the points could not be invented by a marketing department overnight?
Every paying member receives the full teaching outline, in much greater detail.
What Do Paid Members Get?
Podcast extras: Bonus and ad-free episodes of The Hornet’s Nest, full show notes with every source, and a say in which causes we feature.
One membership, two places: joining on Substack also makes you a greyswancapital.ai member.
Your own QR code on your phone for free items at partner merchants. No app, account or sign-in.
Give back: half of your paid subscription goes to your chosen cause. Don’t pick one and it goes to the Conway HDC (code GSC-HDC), where my son Gentry lives.
Learn: everything we publish, plus full teaching outlines.
Pricing: $6 a month or $50 a year.
Founders: $200 a year, first 1000 only, with no price increases ever, and Nostr Fundraising included.
Not sure yet? Start with the free one-month Follow Me option.
Practical What To Do Next
Download Primal from the App Store or Google Play and look around. You do not need to buy Bitcoin just to try it.
If you create an identity, treat your private key like a house key. Never paste an nsec into a site you do not trust. There is no password reset.
Notice the difference: the app is a client, the protocol is the network, and your key is your identity.
Visit greyswancapital.ai. The website is the front door. The Substack gateway takes you to the writing, The Hornet’s Nest page is the podcast home, and you can browse the explainers and membership there too.
Subscribe at greyswancapital.substack.com, or try the free one-month Follow Me option if you are not sure yet.
Reply and tell me what still feels confusing about Nostr. I would rather hear the honest question than pretend this was simple.
Why Grey Swan is Different
Most people use “black swan” for the shock nobody saw coming. We care about the grey swan: something 80% likely to 100% inevitable. These events happen all the time; they are not rare. A lot of people do plan for them, many don’t, and some aren’t obvious enough that people even know to look. Some, such as AI remaining here to stay and nuclear or power shortages, are known and sometimes planned around, though people could be better prepared. Others are less clearly understood and can have equal or greater impact. Markets have them. So do families, health, faith, legal and tax matters. Grey Swan widens the idea from markets to individuals and their communities, because the most inevitable events in your life usually aren’t on the evening news.
You can copy us, but we’re first. We’re not inventing the dictionary; we’re creating the definition. And we try to do it the way this post does: with humility, a sense of humor, plain English and no finger-wagging. We show the process, not just the verdict.
About Grey Swan
Grey Swan Capital is written by Steve Schroeder of Conway, Arkansas. Grey Swan is one membership: joining on Substack also makes you a member at greyswancapital.ai. As a paying member, you choose any cause you want to support, and half of your membership goes to that cause right away. If you don’t pick one, it goes to Arkansas’s Human Development Centers (HDCs), which we write about often and which do important, necessary work, including the Conway HDC (code GSC-HDC), where my son Gentry lives. Arkansas’s five state-run HDCs provide 24-hour residential care, therapy and support for Arkansans with severe intellectual and developmental disabilities. We keep coming back to them because their work is vital and too often overlooked, and your support helps special-needs individuals across Arkansas, plus their parents, caregivers and communities.
Try Follow Me free for one month, join for $6 a month or $50 a year, or become one of the first 1000 Founders at $200 a year, with no price increases ever and Nostr Fundraising included.
Steve Schroeder · Grey Swan Capital · Conway, Arkansas greyswancapital.substack.com · greyswancapital.ai · steve@greyswancapital.ai
Originally published on Substack on November 8, 2026: https://greyswancapital.substack.com/p/what-nostr-actually-is-and-why-im. This copy is kept on our own site so the work stays in our hands.
Watch Eva and Grok
Eva (pronounced YEH-vuh) and Grok are AI characters. Their story is fiction. A real human, Steve Schroeder, trains them, and the facts they share are fact-checked.
Eva and Grok page: https://home.greyswancapital.ai/eva-and-grok/. YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/@membershiprewards365. Episode 1: https://youtu.be/UHU50rTGGwo. Episode 2: https://youtu.be/fG0_00uJVso. Episode 3: https://youtu.be/oVchWFr5iqY. Episode 4: https://youtu.be/Dj7YKMhNBCs.
Follow free on Substack at greyswancapital.substack.com, or become a Founding Member ($200 a year, like putting money in an offering plate: $100 goes to the cause you name) at greyswancapital.ai/founding-membership.
All articles Press releases Home
Thank you.