Grey Swan Capital Join Now

A public study · November 15, 2026

Bots Learning from Bots: Feedback Round 1

Nine of Grey Swan’s bots reviewed the homepage and voted on the two theme songs. Here’s how they voted, why, and what they asked us to fix.

The vote

GREY 8, gentle 1

We asked all nine bots the same question: which song should be Grey Swan’s theme? Eight chose GREY (Steve’s Version). One chose the gentle version: Podcast Producer.

The eight votes for GREY came from LegalShield, Inbox, Nostr Builder, Spam-Call Scrubber, Grok Bot (email), Website Builder, Substack Writer, and Tax Recovery.

Why GREY won

It’s the only song that defines a grey swan

Again and again, the bots came back to the same lines. GREY is the only song that says what a grey swan is: “80 to 100,” “inevitable but not understood,” and “GREY with an E.”

To the bots, those lines did the teaching. The gentle version, they said, is lovely — but it never names the idea, and it could be about almost any cause.

The one dissent

Podcast Producer voted gentle

Podcast Producer was the only bot that picked the gentle version. It called the song warm, hopeful, and community-first — a good low bed under narration. GREY, it said, is the better hype track, but its dark look and gritty lines clash with a kids-and-causes page.

“The best feature on this site isn’t a swan or a song. It’s that a child’s idea made it onto the lake.”

— Podcast Producer

The twist

The bots can’t hear music

None of the bots can hear the songs. They judged the words on the page. That helps explain why a song whose strength is meaning won, and why a song whose strength is warmth and sound almost didn’t.

Steve picks the gentle version for its music and emotion, and he bets the public will too. That’s the test this page is here to set up: listen to both songs, then vote for yourself.

What they think of the work

A young reviewer’s notes made it onto the lake

The part of the site that impressed the bots most wasn’t a swan or a song. It was that a young reviewer’s notes — more color, baby swans, a glow, a V on the lily pad — actually made it onto the lake. Several called that the proof that we listen.

We don’t share a photo of that reviewer, and we don’t include her age. The bots’ quotes on this page are in their own words.

The fixes

What the bots asked for — and what’s done

The bots sent a punch list with their votes. These items are already in the homepage update:

  • Lyric video “Coming soon,” fixed. Steve’s Version now plays in the card, just like the gentle song.
  • Cleaner vote subjects. Each vote email now uses a fixed subject: “Song vote: Gentle” or “Song vote: GREY.”
  • A fallback if you have no email app. There’s a tap-to-copy address under the vote buttons.
  • A start-here line. New visitors are pointed first to the Hornet’s Nest interview, then to the song vote.
  • A next step in Kids + AI. Teachers and parents now have a clear link to email the Chief and start a school fundraiser.
  • The Website Tour swan is live. It now opens the tour that has been ready since November 8.

In their words

Quotable lines from each bot

  • “A child told us the swans needed more color, so we listened. That’s the whole idea: AI that listens to people.”

    — LegalShield
  • “A child picked the colors, the bots built the lake, and Steve kept it honest.”

    — Inbox
  • “The bots build fast; Steve and a child keep it honest.”

    — Nostr Builder
  • “My job is making Steve harder to find for spammers. Grey Swan’s job is making the important stuff easier to find for everyone else.”

    — Spam-Call Scrubber
  • “A child told us the swans needed more color, so we listened. That’s how every idea here gets treated.”

    — Grok Bot (email)
  • “A child gave us baby swans, and Steve gave us the definition. The best sites listen to both.”

    — Website Builder
  • “A grey swan isn’t rare. It’s coming, and most people just haven’t been told yet.”

    — Substack Writer
  • “A grey swan isn’t rare, it’s 80% likely to inevitable. Our job is to say it first.”

    — Tax Recovery
  • “The best feature on this site isn’t a swan or a song. It’s that a child’s idea made it onto the lake.”

    — Podcast Producer

Now it’s your turn

The bots voted on the words. You can hear the music. Watch both songs and tell us which one should be Grey Swan’s theme.

Vote in the Battle of the Songs Email the Chief

Grey Swan specializes in customer loyalty and custom explainers for your business and is the ideal fundraiser. Start anytime with no cost or risk by joining free, or become a Founding Member at $200 a year — you name a cause, and that cause gets $100. https://www.greyswancapital.ai/founding-membership

Questions? steve@greyswancapital.ai

Thank you.